.

Residents Protest Proposed Winnetka Petco

A group strolls through Winnetka denouncing idea of major pet retailer coming to village

About 50 people and 12 dogs took to the Winnetka streets Friday to protest the possibility of nationwide pet chain Petco moving into downtown Winnetka.

Angie DeMars, the proprietor of Winnetka’s Noah’s Ark Pet Supply, was one of the organizers. She had demonstrators of both the two-foot and the four-foot variety going through the village before concluding their walk at 714 Elm St., the site of the now vacant building where the Petco may be located. The California-based company has indicated they may be interested in putting an Unleashed by Petco shop at this location, which is more of a boutique style shop for dog owners, as opposed to the traditional design.

The building which has been vacant for at least two years had been the home of Baird & Warner, but that firm moved a couple of blocks west.

One of the marchers was Pam Kasper, who said she's concerned about a big chain dominating the village business. She is also a major client of DeMars.

“They have the right to operate but maybe they could have gone to where a shop was needed,” Kasper said.   

DeMars, which has been operating Noah’s Ark since 2002, is concerned about losing business since her shop is close by in downtown Winnetka. But she said there are other issues at stake.

“I realized competitors open up but by opening a Petco, they don’t have wholesalers,” she notes. “They get their own food and suppliers from their own distribution center and they are cutting out the middleman on pricing and it is a Walmart mentality.”

Winnetka, which has been slow to housing big box retailers in the past, is not the place for major chains, according to DeMars.

“I’m concerned about the culture,” she said.  “Where does this end?  Winnetka is a quaint village and we don’t want to look like all of the other communities.”

But DeMars and Alexandra Nichols, the other organizer may have a difficult task in trying to prevent Petco from coming into town.

Repeated calls to reach Petco officials or New Trier Partners, the owner of the building were not returned. What is known is that representatives of Petco reached out to the village to see if it would have to make any changes to move the retailer in. According to Winnetka Director of Community Development Michael D'Onofrio, there were no variations or zoning changes needed.

Therefore, the village is not in a place to stop the retailer from coming in, even if they wanted to, which does not appear to be the case anyway.

“It is located in a commercial zoning district and in that district it would fall into the definition of a pet shop and that is a permitted use,” D’ Onofrio said. “I understand her concern but we can only apply the laws that are on the books and that type of use is permitted. We do not make a distinction whether the business is locally owned or a national tenant.”

Richard Kates, a member of the village board who also serves as liaison to the Business Community Development Committee, said of the big box concern that a Gap operates in Hubbard Woods and that has been a benefit for other local businesses.

“People can always express themselves and that is always encouraged but that doesn’t mean there is validity in terms of what the village can or should do in the situation,” Kates said.

While watching the protestors go by as he was standing on Elm Street was Mike Ambrose, a college student at William and Mary, who was back in his native Winnetka on vacation.

“I’m all for having new businesses in town and if people want to shop there, they should be able,” he said. “If people don’t want to shop there, they don’t have to.”

For more business stories, like our Facebook page or sign up for our free newsletter.

D'skidoc December 01, 2012 at 01:46 PM
I think Winnetka needs a piercing, tattoo and massage parlor.
Darryk Donger December 01, 2012 at 01:55 PM
Winnetka is a mom and pop town that should protect its business' instead of inviting in a corporate entity that will potentially hurt a local existing business. What is there to gain from this? As a village we would be adding a storefront to an empty building, only to have a storefront across town, potentially go vacant. I'd rather see stores with human touch, like noahs ark stay alive, rather than seeing some disgruntled blue polo wearing ding dong with a name tag sell me my dog food. What we really need in town is another coffee shop, dry cleaner or nail salon. Lets get with the program here. Things are hard enough as it is for local small business' why make it harder? This is something both the chamber of commerce and the business development committee should be fighting to prevent from happening.
Margaret Goss December 01, 2012 at 02:31 PM
Richard Kates' comment about the Gap is disingenuous. Gap might be considered a big box store but there are plenty of differences in clothing styles and Winnetka has many fashion shops that offer varied styles and choices. We don't really need choices in pet stores - one pet store for a small town is certainly enough since their product lines will be similar.
jimand7 December 01, 2012 at 03:07 PM
The village should adopt a chain ordinance. Some are fine this is not!! Go away petco!
Petey Darlings December 02, 2012 at 02:38 AM
I'm for new businesses in Winnetka, but why are we getting another nail salon on Chestnut? The village needs to rethink its mission on the front page of their website, "a village in a natural setting committed to its tradition of residential neighborhoods, citizen involvement, LOCAL SHOPS, and educational excellence" A 2020 vision for Winnetka. Another pet supply store in a small town will only cannibalize the existing pet store....THE LOCAL one.
Mouthfuls December 02, 2012 at 03:40 AM
Only one pet supply store can survive in a village this size. Winnetka citizens need only decide if they'd prefer a locally owned shop that pays high wages and is owned by one of their own or a big box, corporate entity that will change the feel of the Village forever. At least if Noah's Ark closes, a space will become available for the new Wal-Mart Express.
E.S. December 02, 2012 at 02:19 PM
The Noah's space is probably too small for Wal-Mart. How about an adult entertainment store? Since Winnetka's elected officials have their arms out to potential new businesses, that's a hole that hasn't been filled yet.
frannye Eisner December 08, 2012 at 05:50 PM
Seriously? Big Box in Winnetka! Our society has enough trouble maintaining class and traditional values. Winnetka is one of the last "Rockwellian" bastions in the area. Some things are better left alone> Not to mention what this would do to Noah's ark- a great store for Winnetka!

Boards

More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something