Northfield Trustees Amend Budget, Pledge $50K To Willow Road

Northfield trustees voted Tuesday to use the money to pay consultants working on the Willow Road study project.

Village trustees voted unanimously to appropriate $50,000 in operating funds to the ongoing Willow Road study project at Tuesday’s village board meeting. The motion requires the village to amend its May 1, 2010-April 30, 2011 budget.

The money will pay for services provided by communication and engineering consultant firms that to date have included Kenig, Lindgren, O'Hara, Aboona Inc. (KLOA), All Circo Inc., Hinshaw & Culbertson LLP, Culloton Strategies LLC, and Coopers Civil Engineering LTD.

The only firm mentioned at the board meeting was KLOA, the traffic and transportation planning and engineering firm the village has hired to study road and traffic data produced by the Illinois Department of Transportation. KLOA has been tasked with bolstering Northfield’s case for a three-lane plan with supportive data and to help the non-transportation experts who represent Northfield on the study’s community advisory group (CAG) understand the complex reports IDOT hands out.

“The information is terribly complicated and terribly technical,” said Village President Fred Gougler. “People without an engineering background have a difficult time to understand it.”

Sitting next to Village Manager Stacy Sigman, also a CAG member, at the board table was a stack of papers that reached almost to her shoulders. The stack comprised several hundred pages of traffic analyses and highway manuals IDOT distributed to CAG members.

“We’ve hired technical consultants to provide meaningful meaning to these documents,” Sigman said, noting that KLOA’s consultants have also identified errors and problematic information with some of IDOT’s reports, 50 percent of which have been acknowledged by IDOT, she said.

Part of Northfield’s three-lane-plan campaign has been claiming that the roadway is not solely responsible for the traffic congestion in the area and that widening it will not solve congestion problems. They have been collecting engineering reports and historical data to help prove this point.

“It’s like trying to lose weight by loosening the notches on your belt. You don’t lose weight; you just grow into it,” said Traffic and Transportation Committee Chair Bob Hayward, who sits on the CAG. He was asked to speak before the board and the residents about the need for greater funds.

“We are being bombarded with thousands of pages of paper. We are not experts. No one sleeps with the Highway Safety Manual as their pillow at night,” Hayward said. “We need people to prepare us so we can ask the right questions. … I believe this battle will be won in the end by us if we have the funds to prepare for that battle.”

Before trustees voted, Gougler opened up the meeting to the 20-member audience, for their direct input. A resident and another CAG member gave their support for additional funds, but not everyone was gung-ho.

“We’re talking about a road; it’s not a space shuttle,” said resident Tom Schwartz. “You are asking to spend another $50,000 in a process that has no end. How long will you continue to come back for additional funds?”

He also said the citizens were persuaded to adopt home rule in Northfield with the promise that the village would not abuse its power with excessive taxing and spending.

“The process will continue whether we support it or not,” replied trustee Brian Kozminski. “We’re talking about advocacy. I think we need to support our team to come up with the best solution.”

Gougler said he and Sigman received several e-mails from citizens giving their input. Cook County Board Rep. Jennifer Bishop Jenkins, who could not attend the meeting, asked that her e-mail be read aloud. She said she knocked on doors all over Northfield asking residents to support home rule so that the village could continue to provide basic services, such as law enforcement.

“The village has spent a ridiculous amount of money on this road issue already,” she wrote, adding that she “will have lied to all the people I urged to support home rule if this optional and significant expense is authorized. … Throwing more money at Willow Road is a waste of time.”

Tracy Mendrek, who also campaigned for home rule, defended the fund appropriation, saying trustees have not yet broken promises they made during the home rule campaign, such as implementing tax increases or service cuts.

Gougler said the principles of home rule and Willow Road advocacy go hand-in-hand.

“The idea of protecting character of community are areas we embody,” he said.

The 2010-11 budget originally included $64,550 for “Village Board Projects” in the general fund. The budget was revised in October 2010 to change this line item to $114,550.

The yes vote on Tuesday amends the budget further to bolster this line item to $164,550. Village documents show has pledged up to $50,000 for eligible costs – excluding legal – associated with Willow Road activities, and the has pledged up to $10,000.

At the board’s strategic planning session held Jan. 6, Gougler and Sigman said they project the 2010-11 budget to end with a surplus rather than a deficit, as was originally expected.

The village is currently working on next year's budget and has invited the public to participate in budgeting workshop scheduled for March 8, time to be determined.

The next Willow Road CAG meeting will be held on Thursday, 6 p.m., at New Trier Township High School, Northfield campus, Room C-234.

John Nicolau January 20, 2011 at 02:25 AM
I can’t be the only one that finds it ironic to read comments from a Northwestern-educated attorney like Bob Hayward that includes, "We are not experts", yet he bloviates at each and every CAG meeting I have been to about how the “experts” from IDOT are intentionally misleading both the CAG members and the general public, as if there is some sort of grand conspiracy at work here. If Mr. Hayward is not an expert, how can he be so sure the IDOT folks are either so misinformed or they are intentionally misleading everyone? While I may not have a diploma from a school like Mr. Hayward’s, I graduated from both a well-respected college and graduate school and my thoughts are more in line with a pragmatic Northfield resident like Tom Schwartz when he says, “We’re talking about a road; it’s not a space shuttle”. The fact of the matter is the following simple truth, and that is the approximately 30,000 cars per day on Willow Road can NOT be handled adequately by a two OR even a three lane road, no rocket scientist required to figure this one out. If you want to cut the traffic on Willow Road, then why don’t you close Northfield’s "private" entrance/exit ramps to/from the Edens? Otherwise, widen Willow Road to four lanes and deploy the latest road safety enhancements today's technology can provide. Then we'll be finished with this ridiculous waste of time and money and we can get on with safer lives for ALLl of us here on the North Shore.
Brian Kozminski January 20, 2011 at 06:06 PM
John, let's stick to the facts please and not get personal. We agree that this process is a ridiculous waste of time and money. Northfield is in favor of a compromise plan that could be built tomorrow (and could have been built in 2005) at a cost of $6 million instead of having IDOT spend additional years and taxpayer money once again "studying" the road, while IDOT has budgeted $31 million for a supersized Willow Road. Most of Northfield is content with two lanes. Glenview's Chamber of Commerce wants 4. Let's save the state and local taxpayers a bunch of money, stop the study now, and compromise at 3. It could be built tomorrow.
Carl Bova January 23, 2011 at 12:06 AM
Northfield’s 3-lane plan is safe, preserves Village character, enhances connectivity between interdependent areas N and S of Willow, is livable (meets CMAP’s “Go to 2040” plan), and reduces delay. The plan costs a fraction of IDOT’s $25 million. Kids can cross 3 lanes far more effectively than 4-5 lanes, without requiring intensive safety measures. Chronic problems mean crashes and delays: inadequate left turn lanes, unconnected traffic signals with different cycle lengths, poor shoulders and merges, excess pavement, frequent side roads. The 3-lane plan corrects these, reduces the number of conflict points, and eases motorist decisions. One tool, adaptive traffic signal control, responds in real time to actual conditions. Net result: better traffic flow with fewer stops, delays, and crashes, at low cost. Research shows that adding lanes reduces traffic temporarily, with all benefits lost in about 10 yrs. More lanes induce demand during peak periods. People change their travel habits to the peak period, and others stop using transit. Road diets are reality and working in downtown Northbrook, Wilmette, and Glenview. Road diets complement adjacent land use and preserve & enhance development and community character. Why build a 4-5 lane, costly road now, when the 3-lane plan is more effective and allows for expansion later? Sustainability and floodplain impacts also favor the 3-lane plan Carl Bova - Cooper Civil Engineering, Ltd.
John Nicolau January 23, 2011 at 03:13 AM
Mr. Bova provides interesting input, but to ensure that it’s placed it in the proper context, we need to include the following critical facts to make his perspective more complete. While it may be true that “road diets are reality and working in downtown Northbrook, Wilmette, and Glenview” none of the downtowns in these communities have a state-owned, Strategic Regional Arterial (SRA’s) road running through them like Northfield does with Willow Road. Furthermore, these surrounding villages did not welcome, with open arms, number 53 on the Fortune 100 list of companies to build its world headquarters along that same SRA, bringing increased traffic through its “quaint” little town. In addition, Northfield has also welcomed multiple car dealers and their accompanying traffic (and taxes) just off of Willow. So if we are going to compare what has happened in nearby communities, then let’s make sure we’re comparing the proverbial “apples-to-apples”, such as Willow to Lake, Dundee, or to Lake Cook Roads, all of which are 4 lanes. Each of these 4 lane roads also have countless schools and parks strewn all along them and, with the proper planning, remain incredibly safe. Otherwise, let’s close the ramps at the Edens and Willow so it’s no longer an SRA. Just make sure to block off Willow at Wagner and Sunset Ridge Roads so that Northfield residents, and the cut-thru traffic that they helped create, can take another four lane road to get on or off the Edens.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »