patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Poll: Should Charities Be Allowed To Solicit At Intersections?

Many organizations solicit for donations at intersections throughout the Chicago area.

 

It's a common sight throughout the Chicago suburbs – organizations soliciting donations at high traffic intersections.

Occassionally the practice garners the attention of local municipal governments. In 2010, Homewood voted to ban the practice, despite the fact that the fire department's "fill the boot" fundraiser brought in $25,000 over six years for the Muscular Dystrophy Assoociation, the Chicago Tribune reported.

In banning the practice, village officials in Homewood cited safety concerns and said that roadways were never designed for soliciting, the Tribune reported. However, charities view the practice as a valuable way to raise funds.

In February of this year Mount Prospect also addressed the issued. Trustees voted to limit solicitations to specific intersections, the Daily Herald reported.

In considering limits on such soliciting, Mount Prospect worked with several groups that utilize the practice including the American Legion and Knights of Columbus, the Journal and Topcs reported.

  • Should Charities Be Allowed To Solicit At Intersections?

    (Voting has been closed for this question)
    • Yes. It is a valuable way to fundraise for a good cause.
        33 (20%)
    • No. It's annoying and dangerous.
        128 (79%)
    Total votes: 161
  • Your vote will only count once. This is not a scientific poll. View Results Vote!
Related Topics: Sunday Poll

Jim Wilson

8:26 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

After someone is hurt or killed the laws will be changed

Reply
Comment_arrow

Willie Wilmette

8:44 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

It is a good way to reduce the population of fundraisers.

b garrett

9:00 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

One time per year per "charity". I think several of the I think "legitimate" charities such as the firemen are well worth while. The PROBLEM. Is the "community outreach" that is at most every intersection every weekend. Which has ruined it for everyone else. I highly doubt anyone even knows where the money solicited for that "charity " even goes. Those people walking around at each and every intersection looking at motorists waving smiling looking at you..... Just makes me angry Total rip off I suspect....can't believe it when I see people actually give money! I ALWAYS give to firemen......

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jamiedog

5:58 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

It's kind of like "one bad apple spoils the whole bunch". When it was only a few legitimate charities like the Firemen, MDA, and such--it wasn't too bad, but if they are allowed to solicit, how realistically can any other likely non-legitimate so-called charity be prevented from soliciting?

How about allowing no more intersection/street solicitations of ANY kind, but then instead, encouraging the legitimate ones to only be allowed to do so in front of public stores (where the charity has to get the store's permission to do so). I do think it's just a matter of time before someone soliciting in the middle of a street is hit and injured or killed.

A Concerned Parent

9:18 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

One group had the Walmart in Mt Prospect targeted last week, they had collectors at the end of each aisle in the parking lot - as if Walmart parking lots weren't dangerous enough. I agree with b garrett, some of these collectors don't appear to be with any specified group, just wearing pullovers with "Outreach Ministry" on them. Fireman, American Legion, KoC, I don't have a problem with it, just wish it was done at safer intersections.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Karen Murtha

9:12 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

FYI, that WAS Knights of Columbus last weekend at Walmart. Collecting for the mission of helping mentally and physically disabled children. Standing in the aisle wasn't OUR idea, it was Walmart's. Yes it felt dangerous, as were the shoppers deliberately going out of their way to ignore us...

Comment_arrow

A Concerned Parent

8:50 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Good to know, Karen, that it was Walmart's decision. I gave (and enjoyed the Tootsie roll!!).

Frances Murray

9:24 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

No, this practice should be banned. In addition to these solicitations being wide open to fraud (not all of them, but the cheaters have given the honest charities a black eye), this type of solicitation is dangerous. It's dangerous for the guy with the money can and can be dangerous for the driver who is distracted while digging for money.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Bucephalus

1:11 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Absolutely! Being distracted while sitting at a red light is so incredibly dangerous.

Kelly K

9:38 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

It's way too easy for people to buy a vest with some logo on it, buy a bag of lollipops at Costco and stand there pretending to be with a charity taking people's money! The only charities collecting that way who I give any money to is the firemen (cause they rule) and sometimes the Kiwanis peanut day people. Anyone else is totally suspect to me, in particular those Outreach Ministry people whom I believe are the biggest scam ever in our NW suburbs. I don't believe they are legit even for a second!

Reply

Teresa Solis Pedroza

10:32 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Misericordia yes, K of C yes, Lions club yes, Firemen, yes, these are once a year events and I know these funds are vital to their bottom line - the "others" are there day in and day out and I highly doubt their legitimacy - who are the folks in the all white uniforms with red stripes?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Guido McGinty

11:53 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I don't think you can pick and choose.

Comment_arrow

Sally

7:40 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

You can pick and choose who you give money to.

Comment_arrow

Guido McGinty

8:51 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Of course you can. I thought we were addressing whether or not there should be a law.

Mosaic53

10:44 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

There is always someone at the Lake Cook overpass stoplight every week. They seem to have a badge on but I'd like to know if they really do have permission from the City of Highland Park. I don't object to their presence but to see them there literally every week is way too much.

Reply

irving drobny

11:18 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

not recommended for intersections & in the streets or curbs. they hinder traffic. o.k. for private commercial area (with permission of course) or at municipal area such as parks, in front of libraries or at sports events.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Frances Murray

11:48 am on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Great idea ! Too bad the gods of power who issue permits never thought of it.

llwvrt

12:02 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Most cities/villages require a permit. Solicitors must be wearing vests. I have done this for several causes and I know that there is paperwork to go through along with being a legitimate charity. People volunteering also sign waivers.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Teresa Caldwell

2:21 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

So you sign a waiver to risk your life for this charity? Is it worth it?

Margaret McCarthy

12:28 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Established charities should confine themselves to commercial or public venues after gaining whatever permissions needed -- it is distracting and dangerous to do this at intersections. However worthy the cause, there are safer areas from which to solicit. I have done stints "begging" for causes I consider worthwhile -- hard work, but important. I would not do it at a busy intersection.

Reply

CK

12:29 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

These beggars walk in front of cars and block normal traffic flow. If we dont start driving in a regular situation we can get a ticket. The ones from some drug ministry have cans with big wholes in the tops. Right. They walk all over and we cant make left turns on the arrow.

Reply

IMHO

12:51 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I am so tired of people asking me for money - intersections, street corners, at the entrance to the supermarket, outside the coffee shop, and on the CTA. I am generous and charitable with the causes I support but I get overwhelmed by the constant and insistent begging.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Teresa Caldwell

2:17 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I agree completely with you John.

Comment_arrow

Lois

5:45 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I refuse to give to anyone soliciting in front of a store. I am there to shop, not give to a charity. I give to charities of my choice by sending a check to the organization. That way I know where the money is going (at least supposed to go).

Comment_arrow

Jamiedog

6:00 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Mega-DITTOS to John, Teresa, and Lois!

Comment_arrow

Zuzu

7:16 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Well said Mr. Kerr. I loathe being approach by kids at the grocery store trying to peddle their popcorn or cookies. I flat out tell them no and hope their parents prepared them for rejection in their desperate attempts to raise money. I'm not heartless, but I cannot afford to buy outrageously priced goods every time I am approached. Years ago in the corporate world, it was insane how co-workers would be going from desk to desk trying to sell whatever it was their kids were supposed to be trying to sell to raise funds. Last year, a co-worker was seeking $25 from everyone to send her 6-year-old daughter to some shallow kiddie beauty pageant. Everyone was caving in out of guilt and not have the nerve to say no. I said no. I said in no way was I going to support her daughter into something I am totally against. Twenty-five dollars, indeed.

Diane Romanowski

1:27 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

and why do those outfits look like band uniforms on the 53 exit at Rand, don't even know the charity and don't want to know, looks bogus

Reply

LMS

1:53 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I agree with some of you. I too don't give to the shady ones. Let the ones who serve a purpose to collect, fireman, K of C, The Poppy for the vets, etc......but if you banned these people then you need to ban the Boys and Girls Scout and the bell ringers at Christmas. You can't let some and not let others.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Teresa Caldwell

2:14 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

@LMS - I say ban them all! Especially the ones at intersections! It is dangerous for everyone. We all should have a choice of who to donate too. If people want to help, then help to inform people of the charities by internet and mail, not begging people at inappropriate times and places.

Comment_arrow

Abigail

5:06 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

LMS, the Boy and Girl Scouts and the Salvation Army people aren't in the intersections, so they needn't be 'banned' from soliciting donations. They are in front of stores like Dominick's, Jewel, Wal-Mart, Target, and Walgreens, etc. It isn't a village decision if they stand in front of the store asking for donations, it's up to the store.

I don't have a problem with donating to a legitimate organization when I come out of a store. But this crap in the intersection should be stopped.

Comment_arrow

Lois

5:46 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I've never seen the scouts or Salvation Army at an intersection.

Jim Dewey

3:09 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I belong to Kiwanis, one of the organizations that solicits on the streets. We are limited by our organization's rules and local policy to once a year, and we must always secure permission from the town (Palatine). The village limits the street corners we may use, based on security factors. We secure special insurance for the event. It is a well-organized and supervised event. We receive many thousands of dollars in donations, and funnel all the money collected to worthy local causes; the funds stay in the community.

Sometimes people are irritated at us for being at the stop sign or traffic signal holding a bag of peanuts and smiling, but the usual response is a returned smile and a cheerful greeting, with or without a donation. No one is pressured; all donations are free-will.

As long as it is well-regulated and limited by the local government, it is a safe, efficient way to raise money along with public awareness of the work that our organization and others do for the community every day of the year.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jamiedog

6:03 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Sure, it's "safe and efficient" until a street-side solicitor from even an approved charity is hit by a car or hurt. With all the road-rage and poor economy this days, why even RISK getting hurt just to bring in some funds? There have got to be SAFER ways to solicit funds.

b garrett

3:21 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

of course...politically incorrect to say....but; these' COMMUNITY OUTREACH'/WHAT EVER COMMUNITY THEY REPRESENT?/ guys are all black. and of course will scream 'DISCRIMINATION' IF ANY EFFORT TO CONTROL THEM INITIATED.....ANYWAY/ SOON ENOUGH TOO COLD FOR THEM TO STAND OUTSIDE....TILL NEXT SPRING WHEN THEY DESCEND ON THE NORTHERN SUBURBS AGAIN....HOPEFULLY IF PEOPLE JUST STOP GIVING ANY MONEY THEY WILL GET TIRED OF IT AND GO AWAY OF THEIR OWN VOLITION.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sully

7:46 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Excuse me? They're all black. Funny, not all the ones I've seen around Evanston, Skokie, and the surrounding areas, nor the ones I've seen in Wheaton and the Western suburbs. Not politically incorrect b. - ignorant, false, and just plain stupid.

Comment_arrow

LaVerne

9:22 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Rich people like Sully should be forced to give more

Comment_arrow

Sully

9:50 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I do give, Lucas, but not at roadsides. However, that really wasn't the point, was it?

Comment_arrow

LaVerne

7:39 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

Sully you RICH guys need to give your MORE

Comment_arrow

Sully

8:24 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

I wasn't aware that you know how much I give.

Donna M.

3:26 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

I think it should be limited to once a year and to local charities with chapter within 5 miles of the solicitation area.

Reply

Deborah

3:55 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Yes! It makes people feel good to help a worthy cause and non-profits need the support. Permits should weed out who is a legitimate 501(c)3 organization and who is not. I thank the volunteers who give their time to help Clearbrook and other worthy causes!

Reply

Jeanne Hanson

4:14 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

U r only partly right, b garrett. Your comment IS politically incorrect, but it won't just be the blacks who will be unhappy; the WHITE folks who collect hundreds of dollars will also scream if the practice is banned. Giving money isn't half as dangerous as talking on cell phones, putting on make up, eating and drinking, reading the paper (yep!) and a host of other multi-tasking distractions I've seen while collecting money for Rotary. Permits ARE required, and charities must have a 501c3 standing. It's a good reminder that every day around the world there are people in need. If you don't give a few coins at least say a prayer.

Reply

Abigail

4:54 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

No, this practice should be stopped. We don't need people clogging the intersections begging for donations at anytime during the day. I don't care how worthy the cause is--it's ridiculous that any suburb does this. Buffalo Grove is too eager to allow this to continue.

Like others posting, I also wonder about this 'outreach ministry' with the white uniforms that look like a band director's uniform or a nurse's uniform. Just how legit are these people?

Reply

b garrett

5:01 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Soon enough we will have destitute people trying to wash your windshield at intersections./as in Mexico/ or steal your watch when you stop at traffice lights/ as in brasil/. 0r shoot you and steal your care/ as in south chicago/! Those outreach guys. Probably gang members in all Likely hood

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sally

7:44 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Yea, I'm sure that's how the gangs are making money these days.

Comment_arrow

Sully

7:49 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Whatever you say, garrett.

Gregg Baker

5:13 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

The government will soon put a stop to those people soliciting money at street corners. It is not an issue of safety, but one of competition for our money. The government wants to redistribute our income as they see fit, not as we see fit.

Reply

Lois

5:41 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

There are already people in the city trying to wash windshields for money. What a rip! I don't think anyone should be allowed to solicit at intersections - anywhere. In the first place it is dangerous. They walk in the middle of the street and almost dare you to hit them. In the second place, how do we know who they really are? They stand out there with a vest on and a bucket in their hand asking every stopped car for money. It isn't like a motorist can ask to see their license or permit to solicit.

Reply

RB

8:38 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

As the Republicans attempt to chip away (with a sledgehammer) at community outreach, social services and other methods of helping the mentally ill, disabled and unemployed....you should expect to see more of this should they succeed.
You won't just be turning down individual solicitors, entire families will be out on the street. Oh, I forgot the elderly. Grandma will be out there too.
As you drive or walk by, don't consider that entitled feeling you always to be a virtue....it surely isn't.

Reply

b garrett

8:50 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Feel free to give whatever you want to those "community outreach" shakedown artists at each intersection! The more you give the more of them will be coming up from the south suburbs to "collect". For the legitimate occasional charities. I'm happy to give. The general degradation of life styles is directly related to the liberal politicians promotion of food stamps welfare and never ending unemployment benefits. "Redistribution" as mr Obama puts it......

Reply

LaVerne

9:14 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

How many of the Charities on the Streets and Grocery store door ways also get Funds from UNITED WAY

Reply

LaVerne

9:16 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

After the Election those corners will be needed for people selling Apples and Pencils

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sully

8:27 am on Monday, October 1, 2012

If Romney wins, you might be correct. Your taxes will go up so the wealthy's can go down. Oh yeah, those are the "job creators".

Comment_arrow

LaVerne

2:38 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

Sully you RICH guys still need to give more.

Comment_arrow

LaVerne

9:13 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

If all the RICH guys like SULLY would give there fair share they wouldn't have to be out their. Obama will take care of that next year

LaVerne

9:24 pm on Sunday, September 30, 2012

Do the Street Wise people have a license to sell Street Wise ?

Reply

kj

12:59 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

No solicitors, please!!

Reply

LaVerne

2:39 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

Need to stop people putting resturant ads in mailboxes.

Reply

Hank

6:46 pm on Monday, October 1, 2012

It's hard enough to text while driving without having to drive around these beggars.

Reply

Neal

11:58 am on Tuesday, October 2, 2012

All I know is if I was out there trying to raise money to pay my childs medical bills, a police officer would tell me I am not allowed to because it is too dangerous. If I want to donate to them I would. How about create a fundraising event instead of harassing people while waiting for the light to change?

Reply

Leave a comment